Pastors Who Faithfully Served at St. Peter’s
| Pastor Julius Zaetschky | 1920-1927 |
| Pastor Henry Bietsch | 1927-1932 |
| Pastor Sigmund Manz | 1933-1937 |
| Pastor Robert Wulff | 1937-1943 |
| Student Alex Weinbender | 1943 |
| Pastor John Abs | 1943-1945 |
| Student Rudolph Busch | 1946 |
| Pastor Herman Brandt | 1947-1949 |
| Student Rudolph Mohr | 1950 |
| Student Irvin Hohm | 1951 |
| Pastor Irvin Hohm | 1952-1956 |
| Student Pastor Oscar Sommerfeld | 1957 |
| Pastor Oscar Sommerfeld | 1958-1962 |
| Pastor Conrad Knoch | 1963-1971 |
| Pastor Roman Alksne | 1971-1977 |
| Pastor Arnold Bablitz | 1977-1978 |
| Pastor Conrad Knoch | 1978-1980 |
| Pastor Glen Sellick | 1980-1989 |
| Pastor Brian Patterson | 1989-1995 |
| Interim Pastor Wayne Liliedahl | 1995-1996 |
| Pastor Laird Borst | 1996-2001 |
| Interim Pastor Luther Lerseth | 2001-2002 |
| Pastor Frank Netter | 2002-2007 |
| Pastor Cindy Ninow | 2007-2009 |
| Pastor Robert Grewe | 2009-2014 |
| Pastor Colin Millang | 2014-2021 |